Is Your Fatigue Hormonal or Metabolic? Here’s How to Tell

Do you feel like you’re running on empty no matter what you do? Fatigue, low energy, burnout – these symptoms plague many people, and it’s often hard to pinpoint the cause. Is it your workouts (or lack thereof) dragging you down, meaning your metabolism isn’t in top shape? Or could it be an underlying hormone imbalance causing the constant tiredness? In reality, chronic fatigue can stem from a mix of metabolic and hormonal factors. Low aerobic fitness or poor fat-burning can leave you exhausted. So can high stress (cortisol), out-of-whack sex hormones, or even deficiencies in key nutrients like iron, magnesium, or vitamin D.

The good news is that each cause leaves clues. In this guide, we’ll walk through the telltale signs of different fatigue causes – metabolic vs. hormonal – and how to address them. By the end, you’ll have a roadmap to determine if your fatigue is coming from your lifestyle and metabolism, your hormones, or a bit of both. We’ll also show how PNOĒ’s breath analysis can help identify root causes by measuring things like your VO2 max and fat oxidation. Let’s get your energy back on track!

Low Cardio Fitness (VO2 Max) and Low Energy

One major (and often overlooked) cause of fatigue is simply poor cardiorespiratory fitness. VO2 max – which measures how well your body can utilize oxygen during exercise – is basically your engine size. If it’s low, you have a small engine and it’s going to feel like you’re sputtering through the day. People with a low VO2 max often experience fatigue, low energy, and even insomnia as common symptoms. In other words, what you might think is a health problem could actually be deconditioning. Everyday tasks (carrying groceries, climbing stairs) leave you winded and tired because your body isn’t efficient at delivering oxygen for energy.

A clue that low fitness is at fault: you get breathless or exhausted quickly during physical activity, and you recover slowly afterward. In fact, a metabolic analysis from BioPeak Health noted that a low VO2 max tends to manifest as “quicker fatigue during moderate activity or slower recovery post-exercise”. The solution? Gradually build up your aerobic exercise. Tip: Start with activities you enjoy (brisk walking, cycling, swimming) a few times a week, and slowly increase the duration or intensity. Interval training can also help boost VO2 max over time. Tracking your progress is motivating – for example, a PNOĒ metabolic test can measure your VO2 max and show improvements as you train. Many people are amazed that by improving their fitness, their “mysterious” fatigue diminishes dramatically. It’s like upgrading your engine from a 4-cylinder to a V6 – you have more power for everything you do.

Poor Fat Oxidation and Energy Crashes

Do you often hit a mid-afternoon slump, or feel like you “run out of gas” unless you snack frequently? This could point to an issue with your metabolism’s ability to burn fat for fuel. Under normal conditions, your body should burn a mix of fat and carbohydrates for energy, relying more on fat during rest and light activity. But some folks have poor fat oxidation (fat-burning ability) and instead rely mostly on quick-burning carbs. They’re the ones who say, “If I don’t eat every 3 hours, I crash.” Essentially, their metabolic flexibility is low.

One hallmark of this issue is feeling fatigued between meals or during endurance exercise because the body can’t smoothly tap into fat stores. As one metabolic health expert put it: “poor fat oxidation may force reliance on carbohydrates, leading to mid-day energy crashes.” If you find that you’re always reaching for a sugary pick-me-up or that you struggle with endurance workouts (you “bonk” early), this could be a sign of suboptimal fat metabolism.

To address it, focus on training your body to use fat. Tip: Try doing some longer, steady-state cardio sessions in your fat-burning heart rate zone (often called Zone 2 training). Over time, this encourages your muscles to become more efficient at burning fat. Dietary tweaks can help too – for instance, cutting back on refined carbs and eating a higher proportion of healthy fats can nudge your metabolism toward fat use (think Mediterranean-style diet). How do you know if it’s working? A PNOĒ breath analysis can quantify your fat vs. carb burn. It will measure your respiratory exchange ratio (RER); an RER closer to 0.7 means predominantly fat burning, whereas an RER near 1.0 (especially at rest) indicates you’re burning almost all carbs. By testing, you can see if, say, after a few months of training, you’ve shifted that resting RER downward (a sign of improved fat oxidation). The result: more steady, all-day energy and fewer extreme dips, because your body has learned to tap into its ample fat reserves.

Stress and Cortisol Dysregulation

We often think of stress as a mental thing, but it has a very physical effect on energy levels. Chronic stress elevates cortisol, your primary stress hormone. In short bursts, cortisol gives you energy (the fight-or-flight response). But when you’re stressed out all the time, your cortisol rhythm becomes abnormal – and that can leave you feeling wiped out. In fact, a common symptom of chronically high cortisol is fatigue. Many people with long-term stress feel “tired but wired” – exhausted during the day, yet restless at night.

How does high cortisol cause fatigue? It disrupts your sleep, for one. Elevated stress hormones make it harder to get deep, restorative sleep, so you never fully recharge. Cortisol also plays a role in blood sugar; too much can lead to insulin resistance and blood sugar swings, which contribute to energy crashes. Over time, your adrenal glands can get dysregulated (sometimes dubbed “adrenal fatigue,” though the medical term is HPA axis dysfunction), meaning they don’t release cortisol at the right times. You might produce too much at night (insomnia) and not enough in the morning (no get-up-and-go). Additionally, high cortisol levels encourage the body to store fat and break down muscle, which can indirectly reduce your stamina and fitness.

If stress is running your life, addressing it can dramatically improve your energy. Tip: Prioritize stress-management techniques as seriously as you would medication. This might include mindfulness meditation, breathing exercises, yoga, or even speaking to a therapist – whatever helps blunt that daily stress response. Physical exercise is a great stress reducer too (just don’t overdo intense training if you’re already burnt out – gentle movement might be better initially). Also, ensure you’re practicing good sleep hygiene to aid that cortisol curve (consistent sleep schedule, no screens late, maybe magnesium or herbal teas in the evening to relax). It’s worth noting that while PNOĒ’s metabolic test doesn’t measure cortisol, it can reveal related effects – for example, if your resting metabolic rate is unusually low, it could suggest chronic stress or undernutrition suppressing your metabolism, which is a clue to look at cortisol and overall stress levels. By calming your stress response, you give your body a chance to rebalance its hormones (cortisol, adrenaline, etc.), and many people find their natural energy rebounds strongly.

Sex Hormone Imbalances and Fatigue

When we talk about hormonal fatigue, most people think of thyroid (and yes, an underactive thyroid can cause tiredness, though that’s more metabolic). But imbalances in the sex hormones – estrogen, progesterone, testosterone – can also leave you feeling drained. In women, perimenopause and menopause are classic examples: fluctuating or declining estrogen and progesterone can trigger fatigue, brain fog, and low mood. These hormonal shifts often coincide with sleep disturbances (night sweats, anyone?) and slower recovery from exercise, adding to the fatigue. If you’re a woman in your 40s or 50s experiencing unexplained tiredness along with irregular periods, hot flashes, or mood swings, your fatigue could be largely hormonal. The estrogen decline in midlife can directly contribute to feeling lethargic (partly by disrupting sleep and possibly by affecting neurotransmitters that influence energy).

For men, low testosterone (“Low T”) is a sneaky cause of fatigue. Testosterone isn’t just about muscle and libido; it also supports motivation and vitality. Men with low testosterone often report feeling weak, depressed, and chronically fatigued. (And yes, women can have low testosterone too – women produce smaller amounts, but those contribute to energy and strength.) Research and clinical observations confirm that low testosterone levels can contribute to fatigue and decreased motivation.

So how do you tell if sex hormones are your issue? Some clues: fatigue accompanied by loss of muscle mass/strength, decreased sex drive, or mood changes might point to a hormonal cause. Tip: This is where lab tests are invaluable. A doctor can check your levels – for women, estradiol, progesterone, FSH/LH (depending on life stage), and for men, total and free testosterone, among others. If an imbalance is found, treatment options range from hormone replacement therapy (HRT) – estrogen/progesterone therapy for menopausal women or testosterone replacement for men – to more natural approaches like phytoestrogenic herbs or DHEA supplements, depending on the case (under medical guidance). Even without prescription hormones, lifestyle can help: strength training, adequate protein, and healthy fats can support testosterone levels; stress reduction and flaxseed/soy (dietary phytoestrogens) might ease low estrogen symptoms for some women. The key is that if you restore hormonal balance, energy can dramatically improve. Many menopausal women, for instance, find that appropriate HRT gives them a new lease on life, alleviating fatigue. And men on testosterone therapy often report their vigor comes back. If you suspect this and your metabolic fitness is otherwise good (PNOĒ test looks normal), then pursuing hormonal evaluation is a smart move.

Hidden Nutrient Deficiencies

Last but not least, those persistent tired feelings could come down to nutrition – not just bad diet quality, but specific nutrient deficiencies. Three common deficiencies that cause fatigue are:

Iron deficiency: Iron is crucial for making hemoglobin, the protein in red blood cells that carries oxygen. If you’re low on iron, your body can’t transport oxygen efficiently to tissues, and the classic symptom is fatigue and low endurance. You might also feel cold, weak, or get frequent headaches. This is especially an issue for women with heavy periods or anyone who is vegan/vegetarian. Even without full-blown anemia, low iron stores (ferritin) can leave you feeling wiped out.
Vitamin D deficiency: Vitamin D isn’t just for bones – it plays a role in muscle function and energy. Low vitamin D levels have been linked to fatigue and poor mood. If you’re indoors a lot or live in a northern climate, you could be low. Common signs (besides fatigue) include muscle weakness or frequent infections (since vitamin D supports the immune system). Many adults have suboptimal vitamin D and don’t know it.
Magnesium deficiency: Magnesium is needed for hundreds of biochemical reactions, including those involved in energy production (ATP). If you’re deficient, you might feel fatigued, get muscle cramps, or have insomnia. In fact, low magnesium has been associated with low energy and even symptoms of chronic fatigue in extreme cases. Stress, poor diet, and certain medications can deplete magnesium. It’s estimated that a large percentage of the population doesn’t get enough magnesium from diet alone.

The good news here is that nutrient deficiencies are usually easy to fix once identified. Tip: Ask your doctor for a blood test for these common culprits – iron (and ferritin), vitamin D (25(OH)D level), magnesium (RBC magnesium is more accurate than serum magnesium). If you are deficient, supplements can make a world of difference: iron supplements or iron-rich foods will improve oxygen delivery and stamina; vitamin D3 supplements (often 2000–5000 IU/day, or higher if directed by a physician) can raise your levels and are often noticed in improved energy and mood; magnesium glycinate or citrate can help with sleep and energy metabolism (and often eases muscle aches or tension). Always supplement under guidance, especially with iron and vitamin D, to avoid taking too much. But addressing these gaps can remove a significant drag on your energy. Many people don’t realize how run-down they were until they replenish a deficiency and suddenly feel the lights come back on.

Testing Your Fatigue: Finding the Root Cause

As you can see, fatigue can come from multiple directions. So how do you figure out your root cause? The answer is to do a bit of detective work with testing and tracking. Start with the basics: consider a metabolic assessment and relevant bloodwork.

A metabolic breath test (like the PNOĒ 8-minute test) is a great starting point for fatigue sleuthing. It will objectively measure your VO2 max, your calorie burn, and your fat vs. carb burn rates. If this test shows, for example, that you have a very low VO2 max and an RER near 1.0 even at low effort (meaning you’re a carb-burner), then you’ve identified a major factor – your fitness and metabolic flexibility need improvement. You can then focus on an aerobic training program and perhaps tweak your diet, then re-test in a few months to see progress. On the other hand, if your PNOĒ results come back showing a solid VO2 max for your age and decent fat-burning capability, then you know your fatigue likely isn’t coming from a fitness issue. That’s valuable information because it directs you elsewhere – perhaps towards hormones or nutrients as discussed.

Next, consider hormonal and nutrient testing. If stress/cortisol is suspect (for instance, you have a high-stress lifestyle or classic “tired but wired” pattern), a cortisol saliva test (which measures your cortisol at multiple times in a day) can confirm if your stress hormone rhythm is off. Sex hormone panels can be done via blood; for women, timing in the cycle matters if premenopausal, whereas postmenopausal levels can be checked any time. Men should get testosterone (and related markers) checked in the morning. And definitely test for the nutrient trio of iron, vitamin D, B12, etc., as well as thyroid function (TSH, free T4, free T3) since hypothyroidism is a common fatigue cause too. It might sound like a lot, but these tests often come back with answers. Perhaps you’ll discover your ferritin (iron stores) is very low – bingo, start iron supplementation and you’ll likely feel better in weeks. Or you might find that everything is normal except, say, cortisol is sky-high – that tells you managing stress is your top priority.

In many cases, fatigue isn’t caused by just one thing. For example, you could improve your fitness and start iron supplements and work on sleep, all of which together finally move the needle. Don’t be discouraged if it’s multifactorial – that’s actually common. The important thing is to methodically rule things in or out. Keep a symptom journal as you make changes. And be patient with yourself; restoring full energy can take a little time as your body adjusts.

To sum up, if you’re always tired, it’s not “just in your head.” There are concrete reasons – be they metabolic, hormonal, or nutritional – and you have the ability to identify and address them. Whether it means lacing up your sneakers more often, dialing down life stress, tweaking your diet, or getting some targeted treatment, you can reclaim your energy. Use the tools available (like breath analysis and blood tests) and don’t hesitate to seek help from health professionals. You deserve to feel energetic and vibrant, and with the right approach, you will again.

Sources: